My Hypothesis: Electric cars do not truly run on clean energy as the source of their energy is not clean. Rushing to electric cars as the answer will not be the correct way to solve our problem although it does help.
Source 1). Gasoline Vehicle Phase out Around the World
Many States and Countries are planning on making electric cars the only buyable cars by 2035 or other times around that. New Jersey itself has passed a legislation that only electric vehicles will be sold by 2040. These goals are great for the environment but there are some downsides that people are not concerning themselves with. The line from where the electricity comes from to when it gets to your electric car is tainted. Many countries are planning on going to all electric vehicles by a certain date, but only British Columbia has actually passed legislation on a ban of the sale of new electric cars by 2040.
Source link: https://www.coltura.org/world-gasoline-phaseouts#:~:text=New%20Jersey%3A%20In%20October%202020,sales%20being%20electric%20by%202040.
2). Electricity in the United States.
While we look at electric cars as the future of clean energy they do not actually run on clean energy. In fact, in the United States cars only run on 17% renewable resources, 20% nuclear, 23% coal, and 38% natural gas if a person does not use solar. A car that runs on almost a quarter coal does not seem like it could be the future to me, but if can if this was to change. The percent of this renewable energy has been growing since the 50s and the diversity of these sources has also increased over time. Wind and solar have skyrocketed in popularity since the early 2000s.
Source link:The US energy administration- Energy consumption in the US
Source 3). Electricity usage in China
Energy Use in China is even worse as their energy usage is 59% coal, and second is 20% petroleum and other liquids. This means that these electric cars in China would run on 79% coal and fuel in China and this doesn’t account for energy lost as it makes its way to the vehicle. Coal usage was decreasing over several years, but in 2018 and 2019 it has started increasing this usage yet again. These vehicles are actually less efficient in China than in the United states.
Source link:The US energy administration- Energy consumption in China
Source 4).Coal and the Environment
So what is the issue with coal? The issue with coal is that it causes much pollution such as emitting Sulfur dioxide which causes acid rain, Nitrogen oxides which cause smog and lung illness, carbon dioxide, and even mercury and heavy metals. This means that it is not just bad for the environment but also for us. This is the most concerning percentage of electricity production.
Source 5). Environmental impacts of Solar Power.
We can use other sources for energy such as solar, but these even solar has some drawbacks. Unlike wind that can share land for agriculture solar does not have this availability. The downside of solar is that it takes up land, they use a lot of water, and can use very hazardous chemicals that if not taken care of properly causes risks. This can be dangerous for workers making them as they can inhale silicon dust. Many safety precautions are put in place for the safety of the workers and making sure the products are disposed of safely. The pros outweigh the cons when it comes to solar energy, but people will have to realize more electricity will be used as more cars become electric making these solar farms having to grow largely in size to keep up. The diversity in energy is the best option as differing areas across the globe have different abilities to produce electricity because of their environment.
Source link: https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/environmental-impacts-solar-power#:~:text=The%20potential%20environmental%20impacts%20associated,solar%20thermal%20plants%20(CSP).
Status of Research.
I have already found many more sources for the topic of clean energy, and also how we will have to adapt/ build over the next decade. My main focus for the next five sources will be how much more energy we will have to produce in order to keep up with the larger demand of electricity. How will we build all these plants before 2035 and what kind of electricity should we focus on and where? There is no lack of sources on the matter of clean energy or information on our energy consumption, but there are not many talking about the awareness of electric vehicles not being run on majority clean energy. Much of my work is finding these dots and making connections which is going well.
What does this mean?
Truly a ban on electric cars?
Here’s some very good news for you:
Be delighted if you find NO sources that “talk about electric vehicles being run on dirty energy.” That’s your chance to add something fresh to the conversation.
I wonder if a direct comparison could be made between burning gasoline (derived from oil take from the ground) and using electricity generated by burning natural gas (taken from the ground). I’ll bet it’s a wash by the time you deduct the power lost in the transmission lines from the power plant to the outlet you plug your car into.
I think the category you might have to concentrate on in your Definition Argument is “environmental friendliness,” Swimming. The electric vehicle usually gets credit for being environmentally friendly, but that only because is doesn’t emit greenhouse gases from the exhaust pipe like gasoline cars. You’ve begun to focus on the many ways the calculations need to be done before awarding any sort of vehicle a prize for being “green.”
As you make revisions (and additions) to this post, please ask questions, solicit advice, run test arguments past me here in the Reply space. And make liberal use of the Feedback Please and Regrade Please categories to stay in touch, beginning now by Replying to this feedback.
Thank you for your feedback. I actually made a typo by writing the banning of electric cars in the first part. I will be focusing on environmental friendliness, but also I found some interesting sources on firefighting training that I found very interesting. This has to do with the toxic fumes emitted from these when they catch fire and how these batteries can “run away” and then catch fire. These cars also can not be put out with water or regular foam so many adaptations would be needed to be made. Another idea is looking into how these cars are disposed of as I assume there are some techniques but I want to find what happens when these cars are not disposed of properly. I am also looking into how much more electricity will need to be produced in order for every car to be electric by 2035.
The battery problem is huge, as it is with all renewables/sustainables. The environmental costs of mining for the needed minerals, along with, as you suggest, the hazards of disposing them, are excluded from most comparisons of fossil fuel production vs “greener” generation sources.